Skip to content

Why Blockbuster really failed (it wasn't Netflix)

Blockbuster was destroyed by Netflix.

Netflix didn't kill Blockbuster. Blockbuster did.

It had a working answer to Netflix. Then a new boss switched it off.

Why Blockbuster really failed (it wasn't Netflix)

What happened

  1. Blockbuster passed. One Netflix founder says they were laughed out of the room. Blockbuster's boss at the time disputes that he was at such a meeting.
  2. By 2007 Blockbuster's own online service was growing faster than Netflix, which lost subscribers for the first time.
  3. A new boss raised prices and ended the free in-store swaps. September 2010: Blockbuster filed for bankruptcy.

Every fact, with sources

  • Blockbuster

    The first Blockbuster opened in Dallas in 1985, started by David Cook, a software developer.

    Two sources
    • Quartz
    • Business Insider
  • Blockbuster

    Viacom bought Blockbuster for $8.4 billion in 1994.

    Two sources
    • Quartz
    • Business Insider
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster had about 9,000 stores at its 2004 peak.

    Two sources
    • Quartz
    • AP
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster took in about $800 million in late fees in 2000, roughly 16% of revenue.

    Two sources
    • CNBC
    • Marc Randolph, That Will Never Work
  • Blockbuster

    In 2000 Netflix's founders met Blockbuster in Dallas and asked for $50 million. Blockbuster declined.

    Two sources
    • Marketplace
    • Fortune
  • Blockbuster

    Netflix co-founder Marc Randolph says Blockbuster "laughed us out of the room". John Antioco, Blockbuster's boss at the time, says he was not at any meeting where a sale came up.

    Two sources
    • Fortune
    • Next TV
  • Blockbuster

    Reed Hastings said Blockbuster had thrown "everything but the kitchen sink" at Netflix. The next day a box arrived from Blockbuster with a kitchen sink in it.

    Two sources
    • CNBC
    • Fast Company
  • Blockbuster

    In 2004 Blockbuster took on more than $900 million of debt to pay a one-off $5 a share dividend as it split from Viacom.

    Two sources
    • Blockbuster SEC filings (2005)
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster ended late fees on 1 January 2005, and projected they would have added $250 to $300 million of operating income that year.

    Two sources
    • Blockbuster annual reports (FY2004, FY2005)
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster's online subscribers grew from 1.4 million in mid-2006 to 3.6 million in mid-2007.

    Two sources
    • Blockbuster 8-K, 26 July 2007
    • Salon
  • Blockbuster

    Netflix lost 55,000 subscribers in the second quarter of 2007, its first ever decline.

    Two sources
    • Netflix Q2 2007 earnings call
    • NBC News
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster's board settled a dispute over John Antioco's 2006 bonus in March 2007, and he agreed to leave by the end of the year.

    Two sources
    • Blockbuster SEC filing (March 2007)
    • CNBC
  • Blockbuster

    Jim Keyes, Blockbuster's next chief executive, said in December 2008: "Neither RedBox nor Netflix are even on the radar screen in terms of competition."

    Two sources
    • The Motley Fool (original interview)
  • Blockbuster

    Blockbuster filed for Chapter 11 on 23 September 2010 with about $1 billion of debt.

    Two sources
    • AFP
    • AP
  • Blockbuster

    Dish Network won Blockbuster at auction in 2011 with a bid valued at about $320 million.

    Two sources
    • TechCrunch
    • AFP
  • Blockbuster

    Carl Icahn later wrote in Harvard Business Review that Blockbuster's online plan might have helped fend off Netflix.

    Two sources
    • Home Media Magazine
    • Digital Tonto